Christopher Jernigan

24 Years Behind Bars: The Case Against Christopher Jernigan Is Dismissed

On July 30, 2001, 70-year-old Frank Knight was found beaten to death in room 7 of Sue’s Motel in Mina, Nevada. His jugular had been cut with an 18-inch machete left near his body. His pockets were turned out, and a blood-stained baggie sat in an open dresser drawer. Guests next door said they heard drawers opening and closing around 2 a.m.

Knight was known locally for dealing drugs and trading guns. Months earlier, his mobile home had caught fire under suspicious circumstances.

The first suspect

Police first focused on Jeremy Mullen. He had visited Knight’s room that night, and a notebook at the scene showed he owed Knight $1,000. After the murder, Mullen was seen with a sack of guns and drugs, admitted he had two of Knight’s guns, and had been seen with a similar black-handled machete months before. The day after the killing, he tried to borrow a neighbor’s ATV to “leave the country.”

A witness changes her story

Sylvia Brown, who had criminal charges pending and a husband in jail, first told police that 29-year-old Christopher Jernigan, released from prison that same morning, had simply walked her home from the Pink Elephant tavern.

Then investigators turned off the tape recorder. When it came back on, Brown said she had gone with Jernigan to Knight’s room, watched him punch Knight, and later heard him confess to slitting Knight’s throat. Jernigan was arrested on August 2, 2001.

Trial and conviction

At trial in 2002, Brown admitted that prosecutors had dropped her charges and secured her husband’s release in exchange for her testimony. DNA showed Knight’s blood on the machete and on Jernigan’s boot, but Jernigan’s DNA was not found under Knight’s fingernails or on a hair from his palm. A second witness claimed Jernigan confessed to her in a store; his friend, who was with him, said that never happened.

Jernigan testified that he went to the motel looking for his sister, punched Knight twice when Knight reached for a gun in a drawer, and left him bleeding but alive.

The jury convicted him on September 27, 2002. He was later sentenced to two consecutive life terms with parole eligibility after 20 years. His federal appeals failed, with the Ninth Circuit calling the case against him “overwhelming.”

New evidence

The Rocky Mountain Innocence Center took on the case and found what the trial defense had missed. On tape, investigators had offered to help Brown’s jailed husband before she changed her story. Brown had also said she loved Mullen and “can’t let anyone think” he did it.

New DNA testing of the machete handle, Knight’s pockets and the baggie was analyzed by Cybergenetics in 2022. Jernigan was excluded. An unknown man’s DNA appeared on the baggie and Knight’s pocket and could not be ruled out on the machete handle.

Case dismissed

In May 2024, Judge Jim Shirley vacated the conviction and ordered a new trial, and the Nevada Supreme Court upheld that decision in 2025. Ahead of the retrial, the defense argued that key witnesses had died and that police had failed to preserve or collect important evidence.

Mineral County District Attorney Ryan McCormick, a one-person office, also moved to dismiss. Clark County prosecutors had reviewed the case and called it “not winnable.”

On October 8, 2026, Judge R. Bryce Shields dismissed the case. Christopher Jernigan walked free after more than 25 years in prison.